Scientists from the South Dakota School of Mines and Technology and Michigan State, Toledo and Wisconsin universities have found bifacial perovskite PV cells have the potential to become more environmentally friendly than conventional crystalline silicon devices, due to their increased energy yield.
The scientists examined sites at Toledo, in Ohio and Golden, Colorado, to take account of high and low latitude and humidity conditions. The researchers analyzed the environmental impact of single-junction, bifacial perovskite cells with high and low bandgaps, and multi-junction devices of the same type with two-terminal (2T) and four-terminal (4T) structures. They quantified the life cycle energy production from the cells under real-world conditions and benefiting from diverse albedo environments including installation above sandstone, concrete, grass and snow.
With two-terminal perovskite cells already showing a similar environmental impact to their crystalline counterparts, the potential is there for other perovskite devices to reach parity, claim the researchers.
Currently, the researchers concluded, only single-junction, lead-based bifacial cells are more environmentally friendly than traditional crystalline silicon devices, in terms of each square meter of active area manufactured. Citing an environmental impact 20-60% higher for bifacial cells – compared with single-sided devices – the researchers said: “The difference can be attributed to the difference in material requirements for glass and contacting layers and the additional anti-reflective coating (ARC) layer needed for bifacial PVs [cells].”
While two-terminal perovskite cells had a similar environmental impact to that of crystalline counterparts, four-terminal perovskite devices had 50-70% more of an impact. “The higher impact is primarily due to acidification, eutrophication, human health particulate air and non-cancerous human toxicity impact,” said the group. For all tandem cell categories, the tin-lead (Sn-Pb)-mixture-based absorber is the least environmentally friendly layer.
With bifacial devices offering 9-26% more energy yield than single-sided devices “among all surfaces and locations studied,” however, the researchers added: “Our results show that there are opportunities for all studied bifacial perovskite PV structures to become more environmentally friendly than c-Si cells.”